Finite-Jet Sign Rigidity on Hyperplane Arrangements
and Denjoy–Carleman Realization
Quantitative additions — 13 October 2026
Scope clarifications and revision record — 14 October 2026
Abstract
Let be a finite real affine hyperplane arrangement. We study which -valued chamber labelings can occur as the sign of a function with prescribed regularity. A first nonzero homogeneous Taylor term inherits the chamber signs weakly, and factor multiplicities force a constant crossing parity. This gives a short arrangement-level proof of the known smooth signature-flatness obstruction and, in finite regularity, explicit orthant and arrangement rigidity statements.
For normalized compactwise Roumieu Denjoy–Carleman classes , the Denjoy–Carleman criterion yields an exact realization dichotomy. In the quasianalytic case the realizable chamber laws are precisely the signed parity laws; in the non-quasianalytic case every chamber labeling is realized by explicit selector formulas. Thus an arrangement of distinct hyperplanes with chambers admits exactly and realizable sign laws in the two regimes. We also record corner-margin consequences and a fixed-dimensional polynomial comparison on a cube with coordinate-wall strips of width removed: signed parity has constant exact degree, non-affine laws have degree , and any nonconstant law requires degree under a global amplitude bound and fixed margin . The smooth obstruction, positive-flat existence, and approximation ingredients are classical; the contribution is their explicit formulation and synthesis, with finite-order statements and complete reductions.
2020 Mathematics Subject Classification. 26E10, 52C35.
Keywords. finite jets; hyperplane arrangements; Denjoy–Carleman classes; quasianalyticity; sign distributions; polynomial sign representation.
1 Introduction
A Boolean truth table is finite. Requiring the same truth value throughout an entire orthant of is not. This distinction becomes sharp when the Boolean value is extracted from the sign of a smooth real-valued function.
For example, the polynomial
is positive in the first and third quadrants and negative in the other two. With positive interpreted as and negative as , it realizes equivalence (XNOR), an affine Boolean function over . By contrast, the AND sign pattern is positive only in the positive-positive quadrant and negative in the other three. The nonsmooth function has exactly that sign pattern, but the results below show that any smooth realization of AND on all four quadrants must be flat at the origin. In a quasianalytic class this is impossible for a nonzero function; in a non-quasianalytic class it is possible by using flat one-sided selectors.
The first purpose of this paper is to isolate the local mechanism behind that phenomenon. It is not coordinate division, resolution of singularities, or a special feature of one ultradifferentiable class. It is the first nonzero homogeneous Taylor term. If a smooth function has a nonzero finite jet at the common corner, its leading polynomial already inherits the orthant signs in a weak sense. Polynomial factorization across coordinate hyperplanes then forces an affine parity law. The last factor-multiplicity step is elementary and has clear antecedents; the point of the finite-jet formulation is that it transports that obstruction from polynomials to arbitrary smooth germs and makes the subsequent regularity classification immediate.
The second purpose is to carry that mechanism to a finite affine hyperplane arrangement. If a smooth function is nonzero off the arrangement and has no flat point on it, the local leading polynomial at each point fixes a crossing parity for every incident hyperplane. Those parities propagate along each connected affine hyperplane and hence determine the sign on every chamber.
The third purpose is to combine these smooth statements with the classical Denjoy–Carleman theorem. We use throughout one compactwise Roumieu convention,
and no derivative-stability assumption. In this normalization the quasianalytic criterion is
On the divergent side, quasianalyticity rules out the flatness required by a non-affine orthant law. On the convergent side, a classical compactly supported cutoff yields a one-sided selector, from which arbitrary Boolean laws are assembled without cancellation.
Prior work and contribution boundary. The arrangement obstruction belongs to the signature-flatness theory of Broglia and Tognoli [12]; Remark 4.6 gives the precise reduction from the hypotheses used here, including the homological point in their theorem. Their factorization analysis also contains the parity-of-multiplicity mechanism underlying Lemma 3.1, and their examples already use a first nonzero Taylor coefficient to detect incompatible crossing parities. Thus neither the smooth obstruction nor the leading-term idea is claimed as new.
The broader historical setting includes distributions of signs and signatures [5, 1, 2, 4, 3], the Varchenko–Gelfand algebra of chamber functions and its later arrangement-theoretic extensions [7, 8, 6], and the classical Denjoy–Carleman theory of quasianalyticity, cutoffs, and positive-flat functions [14, 13, 15]. Stronger division and monomialization frameworks are also available [11, 9, 10], but they are not needed for the elementary proofs below.
Exact Boolean sign operations also have a classical constructive theory in the -function literature. Shapiro’s survey [16, Sections 3.3 and 3.6] describes root-based conjunction and disjunction and their finite-differentiability upgrades. These supply direct examples at the boundary of the finite-jet statements; they are credited explicitly in Section 8.3.
The note combines explicit finite-order rigidity, a self-contained proof for affine arrangements, and exact realization classifications with constructive formulas and chamber counts. Section 7 adds quantitative consequences: Taylor estimates turn vanishing jets into corner-margin bounds, while classical rational approximation, Sherstov’s majority-conjunction lower bound [17], and Bernstein–Jackson inequalities [18] give a fixed-dimensional degree classification after excluding the walls. These are derived consequences, with no claim of historical firstness or new approximation machinery. They distinguish exact realization near the common corner from sign correctness at a positive distance from the walls.
Organization. Section 2 fixes the sign and Denjoy–Carleman conventions. Section 3 proves the weak-sign polynomial lemma. Section 4 establishes finite-jet rigidity and the smooth arrangement theorem. Section 5 constructs one-sided selectors and proves the whole-orthant dichotomy. Section 6 gives the arrangement classification and exact counts. Section 7 derives corner-margin and polynomial-degree bounds. Section 8 records counterexamples and comparisons with -functions and normal-crossing results.
2 Definitions, conventions, and classical input
2.1 Orthants and Boolean sign laws
For , put
and define the open orthant
A function defined on an open set meeting all these orthants realizes a Boolean law on the orthants in if is nonzero on their intersections with and
Local realization at the common corner means realization on a centered ball contained in ; global realization means . We call affine if
where denotes addition in . There are affine Boolean functions. When , these are all four unary Boolean functions.
A smooth function is flat at if for every multi-index .
Definition 2.1 (Taylor-quasianalytic class). For the two generic corollaries below, a smooth function class is called Taylor-quasianalytic if, at every point of its domain, a function whose full Taylor jet vanishes has zero germ there. For a vector space of germs, this zero-jet implication is equivalent to injectivity of the Taylor map. Only the zero-jet implication is used in the two generic corollaries below. No division, composition, or sheaf axiom is intended by this shorthand. The divergent Denjoy–Carleman classes used later have this property by the Denjoy–Carleman theorem.
2.2 Affine arrangements
Let
be a finite family of distinct proper affine hyperplanes, where each nonconstant affine defining form is fixed once and for all. A chamber is a connected component of
We write for the chamber set. On a chamber , every is constant. A chamber labeling is a signed parity law if
|
| (1) |
The word “signed” is deliberate: when , this is not literally a group character, and the realized chamber sign vectors need not form a group.
2.3 One Denjoy–Carleman convention
Throughout Sections 5–6, a normalized weight means a sequence such that
with nondecreasing and log-convex. For an open set , define the compactwise Roumieu class by requiring that for every compact there exist such that
|
| (2) |
This convention keeps the factorial outside . To compare with the common total-weight convention, set
Then is a weight sequence in the sense used in [14]: it is positive and log-convex, , and . Its quotient sequence satisfies
so the Denjoy–Carleman series is precisely
|
| (3) |
The Denjoy–Carleman theorem says that is quasianalytic exactly when (3) diverges; see [14, Theorem 3.6]. In the convergent case, nontrivial compactly supported functions exist; the cutoff form we use is supplied, for example, by [14, Corollary 3.12].
We will need only elementary closure properties in addition to this classical input.
Lemma 2.2 (Elementary closure). For a normalized weight , the class is closed under finite sums, finite products, translations, and precomposition with affine linear functionals. For functions on it is also closed under the primitive .
Proof. Only products and primitives need comment. Log-convexity with implies . Combining this with Leibniz’ rule and the bounds (2) gives the same form of estimate with a larger radius constant.
For a one-variable , define . On a compact interval, itself is bounded. For , , and monotonicity of gives
for suitable enlarged constants. For an affine functional and a one-variable function , the chain rule gives
The image of a compact set is compact, and the factors from are absorbed into the radius constant. Translations are the one-variable special case of slope one. □
3 A weak-sign polynomial lemma
The finite-jet argument rests on an elementary fact: even a weak chamber sign prescription for a nonzero polynomial has parity form.
Lemma 3.1 (Polynomial weak-sign lemma). Let be a finite family of distinct proper affine hyperplanes in , with fixed defining forms . Let be a nonzero real polynomial. Suppose numbers are assigned to the chambers and satisfy
|
| (4) |
Then there are unique and such that
|
| (5) |
The polynomial is allowed to vanish at points inside a chamber.
Proof. For each , let be the largest exponent for which divides , and write
The restriction of to is therefore a nonzero polynomial on and cannot vanish on a relatively open subset of .
Consider two chambers sharing a facet contained in . In the relative interior of that facet choose a point outside every other hyperplane and with . In a sufficiently small ball about , the sign of is fixed, while changes sign when is crossed. Hence the sign of changes by the factor . Wherever , the weak inequality (4) forces its sign to equal the prescribed chamber sign. Thus every adjacency across has the same ratio
Put .
Now divide the chamber label by . The quotient is unchanged across every chamber adjacency. The chamber adjacency graph is connected: choose interior points of two chambers and perturb a segment, or use a two-segment polygonal path, so that it meets the hyperplanes transversely and never meets two at the same time. The quotient is therefore a single constant , proving (5).
For uniqueness, fix and choose a point of outside all other hyperplanes. The two local chambers on its two sides differ only in the sign of , so their label ratio determines . One chamber then determines . □
Remark 3.2. The content of Lemma 3.1 is elementary polynomial factorization plus chamber adjacency. We use it as a transparent engine for the smooth results; we do not attach an independent novelty claim to it.
4 Finite-jet rigidity
4.1 Orthants
Theorem 4.1 (Finite-jet rigidity). Let be on a neighborhood of the origin in . Assume that in some ball centered at the origin,
Because each is connected, continuity makes the sign of constant there; write the resulting local orthant sign law as . If at least one derivative of at the origin is nonzero, then there are unique and such that
|
| (6) |
Equivalently, every smooth realization of a non-affine Boolean orthant law is flat at the origin.
Proof. Let be the least order of a nonzero derivative of at the origin; is allowed. The first nonzero homogeneous Taylor term is
For any with no zero coordinate, Taylor’s formula along the ray , , gives
By the nonvanishing hypothesis and connectedness just noted, has sign for every sufficiently small ,
Thus the nonzero polynomial satisfies a weak sign prescription on the coordinate-hyperplane arrangement. Lemma 3.1 gives (6) and its uniqueness.
Under the identification , a sign law of the form (6) is equivalent to an affine Boolean function . The contrapositive gives the flatness statement. □
Remark 4.2 (Finite regularity). The proof uses only the first nonzero Taylor order. If the first nonzero jet has order , then a Taylor expansion is enough. The theorem does not assert that nonflatness is necessary for an affine law: flat functions can also realize affine laws.
Theorem 4.3 (Finite-order orthant rigidity). Let and let be near the origin, nonzero whenever all coordinates are nonzero in some centered ball. If every derivative of order vanishes at the origin and at least one derivative of order is nonzero, then the local orthant sign law is affine parity.
Proof. The order- Taylor expansion supplies the same nonzero leading homogeneous polynomial used in Theorem 4.1; Lemma 3.1 then applies verbatim. □
Corollary 4.4 (Quasianalytic orthant rigidity). Let belong to a Taylor-quasianalytic class on a neighborhood of the origin and suppose it realizes a whole local orthant law there. Then that Boolean law is affine.
Proof. If every derivative of vanished at the origin, the defining zero-jet property would make the germ of at the origin zero, contradicting nonvanishing on every local open orthant. Apply Theorem 4.1. □
4.2 Affine hyperplane arrangements
Theorem 4.5 (No-flat-point arrangement rigidity). Let be a finite family of distinct proper affine hyperplanes in . Let be nonzero on . Assume that is not flat at any point of . Then there are unique and such that
|
| (7) |
Proof. Fix . Choose a ball small enough that every hyperplane meeting contains . After translating to the origin, the incident hyperplanes form a central arrangement. Let be the first nonzero homogeneous Taylor polynomial of at .
For every direction outside the incident hyperplanes,
The function has a fixed sign on each local chamber because it is continuous and nonzero there. Hence inherits those signs weakly. Lemma 3.1 gives, for every hyperplane through , a local crossing parity .
We claim that is locally constant as varies in . Fix and its ball . For sufficiently close to , choose the local ball contained in and avoiding all hyperplanes not containing . The relatively open set contains a point outside every other hyperplane: the excluded intersections form a finite union of proper affine subspaces of . In dimension one, is a point and distinct hyperplanes do not meet it. A sufficiently small transverse pair near , on opposite sides of , lies inside both balls and meets no other hyperplane. The ratio of the two actual signs of is both and . Thus the bits agree. Since is connected, is a single global bit .
Now consider the global chamber adjacency graph. Across a generic facet contained in , the sign of changes by . The same is true of the product . Their quotient is therefore unchanged across every chamber adjacency. As in Lemma 3.1, the chamber adjacency graph is connected, so the quotient is a global constant . This proves (7). Uniqueness follows by crossing a generic point of each . □
Remark 4.6 (Earlier signature-flatness theorem). Theorem 4.5 is an elementary affine-arrangement case of the signature-flatness theory of Broglia and Tognoli [12, Theorem 4.2]. To compare hypotheses, set
Then has zero set exactly and the same chamber signs as . If has a first nonzero Taylor term at a point of the arrangement, the first nonzero term of is its product with a nonzero polynomial, so nonflatness is preserved. For their homological condition is automatic on because ; the hyperplane components admit global affine equations and satisfy the required connectivity. The case is immediate from the one-dimensional crossing picture. Their admissible signatures reduce, for hyperplanes, to the signed parity laws in (1). This remark records the historical implication explicitly; the proof above is retained because it isolates the finite-jet mechanism needed for Theorem 4.7.
Theorem 4.7 (Uniform finite-order arrangement rigidity). Let , let be a finite family of distinct proper affine hyperplanes in , and let be nonzero on . Assume that for every the -jet of at is nonzero; equivalently, for each such there is a multi-index with and . Then the chamber sign law of is a unique signed parity law of the form (7).
Proof. At each on the arrangement choose the least for which some derivative of order is nonzero. The Taylor expansion gives a nonzero leading homogeneous polynomial and therefore the same local crossing parities as in the proof of Theorem 4.5. The propagation of those parities along a hyperplane, and then across the connected chamber adjacency graph, uses only continuity and nonvanishing off the arrangement. Thus the remainder of that proof applies unchanged. □
Remark 4.8 (A finite-order obstruction). Equivalently, if a function is nonzero off the arrangement and realizes a chamber labeling that is not signed parity, then at some point of the arrangement its entire -jet must vanish. The smooth theorem is a stronger all-orders analogue: it yields a single flat point. The finite-order statements alone do not imply that conclusion by letting tend to infinity, because the point at which the -jet vanishes may depend on .
Corollary 4.9 (Quasianalytic arrangement rigidity). Let be a nonzero globally defined member of a Taylor-quasianalytic class on , and suppose is nonzero off a finite affine arrangement. Then its chamber sign law has the form (7).
Proof. At a flat point, the defining zero-jet property would make the germ of there zero. Every neighborhood of a point on a finite hyperplane arrangement contains points off the arrangement, contradicting the assumed nonvanishing there. Thus has no flat point on the arrangement, and Theorem 4.5 applies. □
5 Denjoy–Carleman realization on orthants
The finite-jet theorem supplies the rigidity half of the classification. The converse direction in a non-quasianalytic class is constructive.
Proof. With , condition (8) is the non-quasianalytic Denjoy–Carleman condition . By the classical cutoff theorem, choose a nonzero real-valued compactly supported function in the corresponding Roumieu class; see [14, Theorem 3.6 and Corollary 3.12]. Translate so that the left endpoint of its support is . Then
and every interval , , contains a point at which is nonzero: otherwise would vanish on a right-neighborhood of , contradicting that is the left endpoint of .
By Lemma 2.2, and its primitive belong to the same class. Define
For the integral is zero. For , the interval contains a point where ; continuity then gives an interval on which , and therefore . □
Classical constructive antecedent. A stronger existence statement is classical. Rainer’s Remark 3.13, citing work of Langenbruch, records positive-flat ultradifferentiable functions for prescribed closed sets in the non-quasianalytic setting [14, Remark 3.13]; see also [13]. Taking the closed set to be the arrangement and changing the sign of such a function independently on each chamber already gives arbitrary chamber labelings, since flatness makes the chamberwise pieces glue with zero jet on every wall. The selector construction above is retained because it gives an explicit formula in the defining affine forms and makes the later counting argument transparent.
Definition 5.2. For a normalized weight , let be the set of Boolean functions realized by some globally defined that is nonzero whenever all coordinates are nonzero.
Proof. Assume first that the series diverges. By the Denjoy–Carleman theorem, is quasianalytic. If realizes a whole-orthant law, then is not the zero function in any neighborhood of the origin, so its Taylor jet at the origin cannot vanish identically. Theorem 4.1 implies that the law is affine. Conversely, every affine law is realized by the polynomial
for suitable and , and every polynomial lies in the class.
Now assume the series converges and choose the selector from Lemma 5.1. For , define
For an arbitrary Boolean function , set
|
| (9) |
By Lemma 2.2, . If , then , while for every at least one factor of is zero. Hence
Thus every Boolean function is realized. □
Corollary 5.4 (Gevrey dichotomy). For the Gevrey class , , with derivative growth , the whole-orthant laws are exactly the affine Boolean functions when , and all Boolean functions when .
Proof. In the normalization (2), take . Then
The corresponding series diverges exactly at for . Apply Theorem 5.3. □
Remark 5.5. For , the two sides of Theorem 5.3 contain the same four Boolean functions because every unary Boolean function is affine. The strict expressive difference begins at arity .
6 Affine arrangements: classification and exact counts
The orthant construction extends directly once orthants are replaced by the realized sign cells of a finite affine arrangement.
Theorem 6.1 (Arrangement classification). Let be a normalized weight. Let be an arrangement of distinct proper affine hyperplanes in , and write .
If the series (3) diverges, the chamber sign laws realized by globally defined that are nonzero off the arrangement are exactly the signed parity laws (1); there are exactly such laws.
If the series (3) converges, every one of the chamber labelings is realizable by such a function.
Proof. On the quasianalytic side, Corollary 4.9 gives the signed-parity form. Every choice of is realized by the polynomial
These restrictions are distinct. Indeed, for each choose a generic point of outside all other hyperplanes. The adjacent chamber pair at that point differs only in the sign of , so its label ratio recovers ; one chamber then recovers .
On the non-quasianalytic side, let be the selector from Lemma 5.1. For each chamber , let
and define
Distinct chambers have distinct sign vectors: a nonempty fixed sign cell is an intersection of open half-spaces and is therefore convex and connected. Hence if lies in a chamber , then and for every .
Given any labeling , set
Elementary closure gives , and on chamber the sum reduces to . Thus has the prescribed sign and is nonzero off the arrangement. □
Example 6.2 (Three concurrent lines). Take three distinct lines through the origin in , for example
There are chambers. A full quasianalytic normalized Roumieu class therefore realizes signed-parity chamber laws, whereas a full non-quasianalytic such class realizes all labelings.
Remark 6.3 (When the counts coincide). Each added distinct hyperplane splits at least one existing chamber, so . The numerical gap is strict exactly when . For parallel hyperplanes one has , so the two counts coincide. Thus the quasianalytic/non-quasianalytic distinction is structural, but its cardinality shadow depends on the arrangement.
Setting | Mechanism | Sign laws |
Smooth germ with a nonzero jet at the common orthant corner | Leading homogeneous Taylor polynomial and Lemma 3.1 | Affine parity only |
function on an arrangement with nonzero -jet at every wall point | Local leading terms plus parity propagation | Signed parity only |
Quasianalytic on orthants | Taylor injectivity excludes the flatness required by Theorem 4.1 | Exactly affine Boolean laws |
Non-quasianalytic on orthants | One-sided flat selector | All Boolean laws |
Quasianalytic on distinct hyperplanes | No flat points plus Theorem 4.5 | Exactly signed-parity laws |
Non-quasianalytic on an arrangement with chambers | Chamber selectors | All chamber labelings |
|
7 Margins and exclusion of the coordinate walls
The qualitative classification imposes correctness arbitrarily close to every wall. Two quantitative consequences clarify this requirement. Throughout this section , with positive meaning true, and is fixed. A non-affine law means one not of the form .
7.1 Corner margins under derivative bounds
Proposition 7.1 (A normalized corner estimate). Let , , and let realize a non-affine orthant law. Suppose that has Hölder seminorm at most , using the Euclidean multilinear operator norm (absolute value for ). Then its entire -jet at zero vanishes and
|
| (10) |
In particular, if and for all sign vectors , then
Proof. Any least nonzero derivative of order at most would contradict Theorem 4.3. Thus all these derivatives vanish. For , (10) is the Hölder estimate from . For , write , , and use integral Taylor remainder:
Substitute for the margin conclusion. □
Remark 7.2 (Smooth derivative budgets). For a smooth exact non-affine realization, Theorem 4.1 gives flatness. If, on , fixed constants satisfy
Taylor remainder at every order gives
|
| (11) |
For use the amplitude bound; for the factorial cancels in the remainder. This is the usual associated-function estimate in the factorial-out convention; compare [14, Section 7]. Coordinate partial-derivative bounds of the form (2), with fixed constants on the same ball (or on a fixed compact subball), imply the corresponding operator bounds after replacing by . In the Gevrey case , , optimization in gives for small . A matching optimal-cutoff assertion for general weights requires additional assumptions and is not used here. These estimates concern spatial derivatives and do not assert failure of an optimization or learning procedure.
7.2 Polynomial signs at positive distance from the walls
Put
Let be the least total degree of a real polynomial satisfying
There is no amplitude or coefficient bound in this definition. For fixed , let be the least total degree subject instead to
|
| (12) |
The amplitude bound covers the entire cube, including its excluded strips.
Theorem 7.3 (Fixed-dimensional degree comparison). For fixed the following statements hold.
- (i)
- If , then for every .
- (ii)
- If is non-affine, then as .
- (iii)
- If is
nonconstant and
is fixed, then
In fact, .
Constants may depend on the fixed dimension, law, and margin. No uniform growing-arity, coefficient-size, or evaluation-cost assertion is intended.
Proof. Parity. The polynomial proves the upper bound. On Boolean vertices, fix coordinates outside . Every polynomial of degree less than has zero correlation with parity, by expanding into monomials and averaging over the remaining independent signs. Strict sign agreement would give positive correlation. This proves (i), including constants with .
A logarithmic upper bound for every law. Let and choose an integer . Define
The two nonnegative polynomials and have disjoint real zero sets, so and on . For , some dyadic node satisfies . Therefore
Oddness gives the negative-interval estimate. This is a dyadic rational construction of Newman type; see also [17, Theorem 2.4].
For , define the multilinear expectation extension
It is bounded by one. If for every coordinate, regard as the expectation of under independent signs with means . Each sign differs from with probability at most , so the union bound gives
|
| (13) |
Choose with . Substitution of and multiplication by give a polynomial of total degree at most , strictly correct on . Hence .
The non-affine lower bound. Every non-affine Boolean law has a non-affine two-dimensional face: otherwise every second Boolean difference of its -valued truth function would vanish identically, forcing its multilinear algebraic normal form to have degree at most one. Fix the other coordinates at the corresponding values. Each of the eight non-affine binary laws is AND after input sign flips and possibly output negation, all of which preserve degree and the guarded square.
Choose an odd integer with . In a polynomial for binary AND substitute
Each magnitude is at least . Thus the substituted polynomial sign-represents the conjunction of two independent -variable majorities on a finite Boolean cube, without increasing degree. Sherstov’s lower bound [17, Theorem 1.10] is . His convention uses for true; input and output sign changes align the conventions. This proves (ii).
Bounded margin: lower bound. A nonconstant law changes along some Boolean edge. Fix the other coordinates at that edge’s values. The resulting univariate slice is bounded by one on and takes opposite values of magnitude at least at . The mean value theorem gives with . Bernstein’s inequality [18, Theorem 24.1] gives, with ,
Bounded margin: upper bound. The clipped ramp is -Lipschitz. Jackson’s inequality yields a polynomial of degree at most with
For completeness, the trigonometric form [18, Theorem 21.1] applies to the even periodic function . Symmetrizing its approximant preserves the error and leaves only cosine terms; converts it to an algebraic polynomial of the same degree. Choose a fixed error and . The polynomial is bounded by one on the whole interval and differs from by at most when . Choose small enough that . Then satisfies (12), by (13), and has total degree at most . This proves (iii). □
Remark 7.4 (Interpretation and endpoints). Positive denominator clearing preserves signs but need not preserve a fixed margin after normalizing the polynomial on . This explains why (ii) and (iii) concern different resources. Constants have degree zero in both models; when , no nonconstant law satisfies (12), since the polynomial would equal a constant on an open box and hence everywhere. The theorem is a synthesis of established approximation inputs. It does not follow from qualitative finite-jet rigidity alone, nor does it apply that rigidity to a polynomial required to be correct only on .
8 Scope, counterexamples, and relation to nearby theory
8.1 Real zero support is weaker than a normal-crossing divisor
If one already has a factorization
with a nonvanishing unit , then the sign law is immediately the sign of times a parity product of coordinate signs. Normal-crossing and monomialization theories therefore provide important neighboring context; see [11, 10]. They should not, however, be substituted for the weaker hypothesis used in Theorems 4.5 and 6.1.
Indeed,
|
| (14) |
is real analytic and has real zero set exactly equal to the union of the two coordinate axes. Its sign off those axes is . But after extracting the generic first-order factors and , the residual factor still vanishes at the origin and is not a unit. Thus set-theoretic real zero support on an arrangement does not imply a unit-times-monomial factorization in the original coordinates.
This is why the arrangement theorem above is stated and proved directly at the sign level. Resolution and monomialization results involve stronger divisor hypotheses and/or transformations of source and target; they remain relevant background, not a replacement for the present argument.
8.2 A common corner is essential for local orthant rigidity
The connectedness of a domain alone does not replace the common-corner hypothesis in Theorem 4.1. On the punctured plane , define
|
| (15) |
This function is real analytic on . It is positive in the positive-positive quadrant and in both mixed-sign quadrants, while it is negative in the negative-negative quadrant. In a mixed-sign quadrant,
because , whereas in the negative-negative quadrant
Thus (15) realizes OR on the four quadrants of the punctured plane. There is no contradiction with Theorem 4.1: the origin, at which the finite-jet obstruction would live, has been removed.
8.3 Classical R-functions and finite differentiability
The preceding root formula is the classical -disjunction. Changing the plus sign to a minus sign gives an -conjunction; see [16, Section 3.3, equations (3.4)–(3.5)]. In particular, for any integer , put and
This realizes AND on the open quadrants. Its smooth angular factor and positive homogeneity of degree give for ; these derivatives extend by zero at the origin. The th derivative is Lipschitz: for pairs at distance comparable to their radius use its size bound, and for closer pairs integrate its bounded derivative along a segment away from zero. Thus and its -jet vanishes. It is not : that regularity and homogeneity would make it its homogeneous Taylor polynomial of degree , contrary to the non-affine sign law. On , , its value is . Hence the exponent in Proposition 7.1 for cannot be increased in general. The construction is classical; the estimate states its relation to the finite-order obstruction.
8.4 Analytic models and restricted domains
A finite composition of real-analytic maps is real analytic on its domain. If a scalar output realizes an orthant law on a full neighborhood of the common corner, Corollary 4.4 therefore forces affine parity. The hypothesis concerns independently variable coordinates throughout that neighborhood; it does not cover merely fitting finitely many Boolean representatives or a restricted set of reachable inputs.
Even an analytic formula can realize AND on every when it depends on . For example,
is globally real analytic. In the positive-positive guarded quadrant it is increasing in each coordinate, so its minimum is . If , then , and the other negative-input case is symmetric. At the common corner , so it fails the positive-positive law sufficiently near zero. This example imposes no global amplitude normalization and does not contradict Theorem 7.3. A nonsmooth alternative is , which realizes AND exactly on every open quadrant.
8.5 Smoothness alone does not imply rigidity
The selector construction in (9) gives realizations of every Boolean law in the non-quasianalytic case. For a non-affine law, Theorem 4.1 says that such a realization must be flat at the origin; the construction is consistent with exactly that requirement. The mathematical boundary is therefore not “smooth versus nonsmooth,” but rather the presence or absence of a nonzero finite jet at the relevant common boundary.
8.6 Signatures and chamber functions
The factor-parity mechanism in Lemma 3.1 is classical antecedent material. Broglia–Tognoli’s Proposition 2.4 records how parity of maximal factor multiplicities controls the induced signature [12, Proposition 2.4], while the subsequent signature and sign-distribution literature studies broader realization and approximation questions [5, 1, 2, 4, 3].
A distinct combinatorial tradition studies all functions that are constant on arrangement chambers. Varchenko and Gelfand introduced the algebra generated by hyperplane Heaviside functions [7]; see also [8, 6]. The present analytic question is narrower: regularity constraints select a small family of -valued chamber functions in the quasianalytic regime, while the non-quasianalytic regime permits them all.
8.7 Established machinery versus the sign classification
Stronger division, quasianalytic local-ring, resolution, and monomialization frameworks are available [15, 11, 9, 10]. The proofs here deliberately avoid that machinery: the rigidity input is only the first nonzero Taylor polynomial, and the realization input is only the classical Denjoy–Carleman criterion together with cutoffs or positive-flat functions. This is the sense in which the note is self-contained without claiming foundational priority.
9 Conclusion
A first nonzero Taylor term provides a compact bridge from local regularity to global chamber signs. In finite order it yields explicit orthant and arrangement obstructions; in the smooth setting the same mechanism gives an elementary proof of the established signature-flatness consequence for affine arrangements. Combined with the Denjoy–Carleman criterion, the argument gives an exact realization classification: for distinct hyperplanes with chambers, the full normalized Roumieu class realizes exactly signed parity laws in the quasianalytic case and all chamber labelings in the non-quasianalytic case.
With fixed derivative bounds, the same vanishing jets control how rapidly an exact non-affine score approaches zero at the corner. Excluding wall strips changes the polynomial problem: at fixed dimension non-affine sign laws require logarithmic degree in the inverse width, whereas a fixed margin under a whole-cube amplitude bound requires reciprocal-width degree for every nonconstant law. The complete reductions make these distinctions explicit. The finite-order formulation, arrangement proof, and synthesis remain the contribution; the smooth obstruction, -function constructions, positive-flat theory, and approximation inputs retain their classical attribution.
References
[1] F. Acquistapace and F. Broglia, Signatures and flatness, Journal für die reine und angewandte Mathematik 425 (1992), 61–70.
[2] F. Acquistapace and F. Broglia, Correction to the paper “Signatures and flatness” (Vol. 425, pp. 61–70, 1992), Journal für die reine und angewandte Mathematik 444 (1993), 155–156.
[3] F. Acquistapace and F. Broglia, More about signatures and approximation, Geometriae Dedicata 50 (1994), no. 2, 107–116. DOI: 10.1007/BF01265306.
[4] F. Acquistapace, F. Broglia, and E. Fortuna, When is a distribution of signs locally completable?, Canadian Journal of Mathematics 46 (1994), no. 3, 449–473. DOI: 10.4153/CJM-1994-024-2.
[5] E. Fortuna, Distributions de signes, Mathematika 38 (1991), no. 1, 50–62. DOI: 10.1112/S0025579300006434.
[6] A. Björner, M. Las Vergnas, B. Sturmfels, N. White, and G. M. Ziegler, Oriented Matroids, 2nd ed., Encyclopedia of Mathematics and its Applications, vol. 46, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1999.
[7] A. N. Varchenko and I. M. Gel’fand, Heaviside functions of a configuration of hyperplanes, Functional Analysis and Its Applications 21 (1987), no. 4, 255–270. DOI: 10.1007/BF01077800.
[8] D. Moseley, Equivariant cohomology and the Varchenko–Gelfand filtration, Journal of Algebra 472 (2017), 95–114. DOI: 10.1016/j.jalgebra.2016.10.010; arXiv:1110.5369.
[9] A. Belotto da Silva, E. Bierstone, and M. Chow, Composite quasianalytic functions, Compositio Mathematica 154 (2018), no. 9, 1960–1973. DOI: 10.1112/S0010437X18007339; arXiv:1709.06629.
[10] A. Belotto da Silva and E. Bierstone, Monomialization of a quasianalytic morphism, Annales Scientifiques de l’Ecole Normale Superieure 56 (2023), no. 5, 1583–1651. DOI: 10.24033/asens.2562; arXiv:1907.09502.
[11] E. Bierstone and P. D. Milman, Resolution of singularities in Denjoy–Carleman classes, Selecta Mathematica 10 (2004), no. 1, 1–28. DOI: 10.1007/s00029-004-0327-0; arXiv:math/0108204.
[12] F. Broglia and A. Tognoli, Approximation of -functions without changing their zero-set, Annales de l’Institut Fourier 39 (1989), no. 3, 611–632. DOI: 10.5802/aif.1178.
[13] M. Langenbruch, A general approximation theorem of Whitney type, Rev. R. Acad. Cien. Serie A. Mat. (RACSAM) 97 (2003), no. 2, 287–303. https://rac.es/ficheros/doc/00128.pdf.
[14] A. Rainer, Ultradifferentiable extension theorems: a survey, Expositiones Mathematicae 40 (2022), no. 3, 679–757. DOI: 10.1016/j.exmath.2021.12.001; arXiv:2107.01061.
[15] V. Thilliez, On quasianalytic local rings, Expositiones Mathematicae 26 (2008), no. 1, 1–23. DOI: 10.1016/j.exmath.2007.04.001; arXiv:math/0509273.
[16] V. Shapiro, Semi-analytic geometry with -functions, Acta Numerica 16 (2007), 239–303. DOI: 10.1017/S096249290631001X.
[17] A. A. Sherstov, The intersection of two halfspaces has high threshold degree, SIAM Journal on Computing 42 (2013), no. 6, 2329–2374. DOI: 10.1137/100785260.
[18] K. A. Kopotun, A. V. Prymak, and I. O. Shevchuk, Introduction to Approximation Theory, study guide, 24 January 2018, Theorems 21.1 and 24.1. https://mathanalysis.knu.ua/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/at-study-guide-january-22-2018-1-1.pdf.